← All posts
Operators · November 6, 2026 · 7 min read

Why Not Just Flare It? Venting vs. Flaring vs. Burning Gas in an Engine

If you are already flaring, you are already doing the responsible thing, mostly. The interesting part is the "mostly." Here is what actually happens to the gas in each case, with the measured numbers rather than the assumed ones.

Ask an operator about putting a flare's gas to work and the first answer is usually reasonable: we already flare it, so we already handle the emissions. Flaring is far better than venting. But the flare destruction efficiency everyone plans around is an assumption, and when researchers went out and measured real flares, the number came back lower.

That gap is the whole story. It is also where the honest case for burning gas in an engine lives, and it is narrower and more interesting than "engines are cleaner."

Three fates for the same gas

Vented, methane goes straight to the atmosphere. Over 20 years, methane traps more than 80 times as much heat as the same mass of CO₂. Nothing is destroyed and nothing is produced.

Flared, methane burns into CO₂ and water. The CO₂ is far less damaging than the methane it replaced, which is why flaring beats venting by a wide margin. The energy goes up the stack as heat.

Burned in an engine, the same chemistry happens inside a cylinder: methane becomes CO₂ and water. For every unit of methane that burns, the CO₂ out is the same whether it burned in a flare or an engine. The differences are how much slips through unburned, and whether anything useful comes out the other side.

What happens to 100 units of methane
Methane that escapes unburned Methane burned to CO₂ Vented: 100 of every 100 units of methane escape unburned. Output: nothing. Vented 100 of 100 escape No combustion at all Output: nothing Open flare: 9 of every 100 units of methane escape unburned. Output: heat, wasted. Open flare 9 of 100 escape Inventories assume 2 Output: heat, wasted Lean-burn engine: 3 to 4 of every 100 units of methane escape unburned. Output: electricity. Lean-burn engine 3 to 4 of 100 escape Uncontrolled, EPA AP-42 Output: electricity Rich-burn engine: under 1 of every 100 units of methane escape unburned. Output: electricity. Rich-burn engine under 1 of 100 escape Uncontrolled, EPA AP-42 Output: electricity
Flare figure: average across roughly 300 flares in the Permian, Eagle Ford and Bakken, Plant et al., Science, 2022. Engine figures: EPA AP-42 Section 3.2 uncontrolled methane factors, 1.25 lb/MMBtu four-stroke lean-burn and 0.23 lb/MMBtu rich-burn, converted to a share of the fuel burned. Exact values move a little with gas composition.

The 98% that measured 91%

Emissions inventories assume a flare destroys 98% of the methane sent to it, so 2 of every 100 units escape. In 2022, researchers published airborne measurements of roughly 300 flares across the Permian, Eagle Ford and Bakken. They found an effective destruction efficiency of about 91%. That is about 9 units escaping instead of 2, nearly five times the methane the official numbers assume.

The detail that matters is why. Most flares in the study did hit 98%. The average was dragged down by a minority: some malfunctioning flares burned as little as 60% of their methane, and 3 to 5% of flares were not lit at all. An unlit flare is a vent with a pipe on it.

Engines are not magic either

It would be convenient to say an engine burns everything. It does not. EPA's published factors for uncontrolled gas engines put methane slip at roughly 3 to 4 units in 100 for a four-stroke lean-burn engine, and under 1 for a rich-burn engine. A lean-burn engine is actually a little worse than a flare working perfectly.

So the case is not that every engine beats every flare. A well-run flare and a well-run lean-burn engine are in the same neighborhood. Rich-burn engines, and engines fitted with catalysts, do better.

Why the engine still wins in the field

Go back to what pulled the flare average down. It was not the flares working as designed. It was the ones that were not, and nobody noticed for a while.

An engine cannot fail quietly that way. When it stops burning gas it stops making power, and on a site where that power is the revenue, it gets noticed fast. A flare that blows out at two in the morning makes no sound and costs nobody money. It can sit unlit until someone drives past.

The short version

Venting is the worst outcome by far. A working flare and a working engine are close on methane. The engine's real advantages are that it does not get to stop working without someone finding out, and that it turns the gas into electricity instead of heat.

That second point is not small. A flare and an engine run the same combustion. One sends the energy to the sky. The other turns it into a revenue stream that pays for the equipment, the monitoring and the maintenance that keep it burning cleanly.

What this means for your site

If you are flaring under an RRC authorization, you are doing what the rules ask. The question worth asking is not whether flaring is acceptable. It is whether the gas could earn something, under a setup that is watched around the clock because it is earning.

There are rules-side reasons to look, too. Every renewal of a flaring exception requires showing a good-faith attempt to put the gas to a legal use, and on-site consumption may also qualify for the HB 591 severance tax exemption.

One caveat: this is a plain-English comparison, not an engineering or permitting assessment. Real results depend on gas composition, the specific engine, and its controls.

Wondering whether your flare could earn?

Send us your daily volume and location. We will tell you honestly whether on-site power works at your site, and what it would take.

Start a conversation